Stay informed
Subscribe to our newsletter, our monthly look at food and non-food quality management.
In a recent episode, the television program Radar exposed the use of erroneous health claims and prohibited medical claims on food supplements. In the European Union, health claims are strictly regulated and medical claims are even prohibited on dietary supplements. As a manufacturer, how do you prevent the use of erroneous and prohibited claims?

Regulation 1924/2006 governs nutrition and health claims for foods, including dietary supplements, in the European Union (EU). A health claim is defined in this Regulation as a claim that states, suggests, or implies that there is a relationship between a food category, a food, or a component thereof and health.
Health claims may not be used unless they are included in the Community list of approved health claims. The claims on this list may only be used if the specified conditions are met.
Medical claims, on the other hand, are claims that attribute properties to a food product related to the prevention, treatment, or cure of human diseases. When a food product or dietary supplement contains a medical claim, the product may fall under the Medicines Act, which imposes specific requirements. For example, medicines may only be marketed after obtaining a marketing authorization. Furthermore, it is prohibited to make medical claims on foods and dietary supplements.
The Investigative Desk investigated claims on dietary supplements for Follow the Money and Radar. Radar highlighted this topic in an episode. In the investigation, the investigative journalists examined the claims on 431 dietary supplements and submitted them to the Dutch Certification Board. The Keuringsraad is a self-regulatory body dedicated to promoting and maintaining responsible public advertising of self-care products by companies. The investigation revealed that nearly 200 of the 431 dietary supplements contained false health claims and even medical claims.
As indicated above, the European Commission has compiled a list of approved health claims that may be used for certain nutrients and foods in conjunction with their scope of application. In doing so, the use of the claims is subject to certain conditions, such as the minimum amount of the nutrient in the food or supplement.
The health claims included in the European Claims Register are formulated in English. It is important to translate these into Dutch as accurately as possible, since the wording is very important in the case of health claims. Even minor changes in wording can render a health claim inadmissible. Fortunately, the Dutch Food Inspection Board has developed a claims database containing examples of permitted and prohibited health claims for each nutrient. In addition, the database includes various wording options and the conditions for use. When formulating a health claim in Dutch, it is wise to consult this database.
So the wording of health claims listens closely. An example of permitted wording of a health claim is "vitamin D contributes to the normal functioning of the immune system. In the database of the Inspection Board you can find which alternatives formulations are possible. For example, the claim "vitamin D supports the body's defenses" is allowed, but the claim "vitamin B promotes the function of the immune system" is not. Indeed, the latter claim implies a healing effect and is therefore a medical claim. In short, although the claims are similar, they may not both be used.
You’re probably familiar with them: claims accompanied by a disclaimer such as “health claim pending approval by the European Commission” or “the authorization procedure for this health claim is still ongoing.” What exactly does this mean? These are the so-called “on hold” claims, as defined in Article 28(6) of Regulation 1924/2006, which often pertain to botanical substances. These are claims for which applications for approval were submitted before January 1, 2008. This was before the introduction of the European Claims Register. These claims have not yet been assessed by the EFSA, or the European Commission’s authorization procedure has not yet been completed. However, these claims may be used if generally accepted scientific advice is available to support the claim and provided, of course, that they are not misleading. In addition, the claims must be accompanied by a disclaimer.
But what if you want to use a new health claim that is not yet included in the European Claims Register? Then as a company you can submit an application, as described in article 15 of Regulation 1924/2006. This application must include independent studies that substantiate the claim and a proposal for the wording. Via the national authority, the application goes through to EFSA for assessment. Based on the EFSA opinion, the European Commission makes the final decision on inclusion in the Community list.
In short, make sure you only use health claims that are allowed and never use medical claims on food supplements and foods. After the recent broadcast of Radar, which also highlighted the response of regulator the Netherlands Food and Consumer Product Safety Authority (NVWA), health claims are likely to receive extra attention. Therefore, look critically at health claims before they are placed on a product.
Contact us at [email protected], NL +31 (0)30 65 66 010, or BE +32 (0)3 616 08 69.
Subscribe to our newsletter, our monthly look at food and non-food quality management.
Is there anything I can help you with?